The BEST White Cheddar Substitutes To Try

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for details.

If you’re like many home cooks, you may have experienced a time when you couldn’t find white cheddar cheese. And finding white cheddar substitutes can seem daunting, but it doesn’t have to be! With the right knowledge and options, you’ll be able to find a delicious alternative that will work perfectly in all your favorite recipes.

In this blog post, we’ll discuss some tasty substitutes for white cheddar and provide tips on selecting the best one for your needs. Whether it’s pizzas, mac, and cheese, or salads that await their cheesy topping – by following these simple suggestions, you will make a winning meal!

But before we do that, let’s make sure we understand what white cheddar cheese tastes like! This will help us find the perfect replacement.

What Does White Cheddar Taste Like?

White cheddar cheese is a mild and creamy cheddar cheese – sometimes referred to as “mild white cheddar” or should not be confused with white American cheese. It has a hint of sweetness and a slightly salty flavor profile. White cheddar cheese is one of the most popular types of cheese in the United States and can be used in various recipes, from mac and cheese to quesadillas, chili, pizza, and more.

White cheddar cheese has a mild and creamy flavor with a hint of sweetness. It is slightly salty and has a buttery texture that melts deliciously in your mouth. Its flavor profile is versatile, making it great for use in everything from grilled cheese sandwiches to macaroni and cheese recipes.

What Is The Difference Between Orange Cheddar Cheese And White Cheddar Cheese?

The difference between white and orange cheddar cheese is primarily visual, as one variety is typically naturally colored a yellowish-orange hue while the other remains white. Though both are made from the same combination of milk, culture, and salt, and even if a colorant such as annatto is not added to plain cheddar, both varieties are considered to be cheddar cheese due to their firm texture and sharp taste.

Orange cheddar tends to have a more robust flavor than white cheddar due to the added artificial coloring and potential variations in recipes that create a stronger taste. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference when selecting which type of cheddar cheese best suits your tastes.

Substitutes for White Cheddar Cheese

White Cheddar Substitutes

All the cheese options below can be used with a 1-to-1 ratio with white cheddar. This means that if the recipe calls for 2 oz of shredded white cheddar, you can use 2 oz of any of the cheeses mentioned below.

Orange or Yellow Cheddar Cheese

As stated above, orange or yellow cheddar is simply the same as white cheddar but with a more robust flavor. This will give you the closest replacement for white cheddar. If you are worried about the color and its effect on the dish, then you can swap with one of the white cheeses below, like Monterey Jack.

Colby Cheese

Colby cheese is a great substitute for white cheddar cheese in many recipes and dishes. Made from cow’s milk, this semi-soft cheese resembles cheddar in flavor but is much milder. Colby is light orange in color because it is treated with annatto, a natural dye made from seeds of the achiote tree.

This gives that wonderful orange color cheese that we all love. As well as adds a slightly sweet, nutty flavor to it. Like most cheeses, their taste varies depending on the age – younger cheeses have milder flavors, while more mature ones are sharper in taste.

Additionally, when cooked or melted, Colby cheese has a creamy texture that complements certain recipes extremely well. All things considered, Colby cheese makes for a fantastic alternative to white cheddar because of its similar texture and flavor profile. It’s a great choice!

Colby Jack Cheese

Colby Jack cheese, also known as Co-Jack, is a great substitute for white cheddar and is often used in sandwiches and recipes. It’s quite a mild-tasting cheese made from cow’s milk which has been blended with Monterey Jack.

Colby Jack cheese has a speckled color of white and orange to it, thanks to the combination of both kinds of cheese. I remember always loving this cheese as a kid because it reminded me of a speckled Holstein cow.

The texture of this cheese is semi-soft and creamy, making it easy to slice or shred for use in various dishes. When melted, Colby Jack cheese will have a nice creamy texture and flavor that can go well with many dishes such as tacos, enchiladas, quesadillas, macaroni and cheese, and more.

It also makes a good topping for burgers and other sandwiches. Because of that, Colby Jack is an excellent substitute for white cheddar because it offers similar textures and blends well with most recipes.

Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack cheese is another great substitute for white cheddar due to its mild but flavorful taste, creamy texture, and versatility. This semi-soft cheese is made from cow’s milk, and it has a pale yellow-white color with occasional flecks of red or green if it’s pepper jack.

Monterey Jack has a buttery flavor and slightly sweet aftertaste; however, this taste can vary depending on its age. As with cheddar, it has a firm texture which makes it great for slicing and grating in recipes. Its high-fat content also makes it a great choice for melted dishes like macaroni and cheese or quesadillas. All things considered, Monterey Jack cheese is a spot-on alternative to white cheddar as it has similarities in appearance being white cheese, taste, and texture!

Edam Cheese

Edam cheese is a great alternative to white cheddar due to its mild flavor, creamy texture, and versatility. This type of cheese from the Netherlands is made from cow’s milk and is semi-hard with a buttery yellow color. It does not have a sharp flavor, making it perfect for most recipes that you need to use swap.

Edam cheese also melts nicely when heated, allowing it to be used in sauces or soups. It’s also great as a topping on salads or pizzas since it adds an extra layer of creaminess and flavor when melted. To conclude, if you are looking for an alternative to white cheddar, then Edam cheese could be a perfect choice thanks to its mild taste and versatile uses! It’s a winner!

Cheshire Cheese

Cheshire cheese is an ideal substitute for white cheddar due to its mild sweetness and firmer texture. This cow’s milk cheese is semi-hard and has a distinctive crumbly texture that makes it easier to grate in recipes. Cheshire cheese has a pale golden-yellow color with a few small holes scattered throughout the body of the cheese.

It also has a sweet flavor which can be enhanced when served warm. In addition, it melts well due to its high-fat content making it great for family favorites like macaroni and cheese, enchiladas, quesadillas, and more. Overall, Cheshire cheese is an excellent substitute for white cheddar due to its mild sweetness and firm yet crumbly texture that works great in various dishes.

Double Gloucester

Double Gloucester cheese is an ideal substitute for white cheddar due to its crumbly texture and mild flavor. This traditional English cheese is made with cow’s milk, is semi-hard, and has a bright orange color thanks to those natural dyes.

It melts well due to its high-fat content, making it great for all the dishes that work for white cheddar! The cheese taste is mild yet savory and slightly sharp when served warm. Double Gloucester cheese also grates easily and is often used in salads or enjoyed on its own. In conclusion, this creamy cheese is a great alternative to white cheddar as it shares similar properties but packs more flavor.

American Cheese

American cheese may seem like a stretch, but it can actually work really well when you don’t have any cheddar on hand. Because of its mild flavor and creamy texture. This type of cheese is processed cheese that is made from cow’s milk and has a bright yellow color. If that’s a turn-off, you can use one of the natural cheeses above.

It has a soft, creamy texture that melts nicely, which makes it perfect for recipes that need extra gooey cheesiness. American cheese also grates easily and can be used to top salads or pizza. While it doesn’t have the same sharp flavor as cheddar, it still adds an extra layer of creaminess and flavor when melted. In conclusion, American cheese is an easy-to-use alternative to white cheddar thanks to its mild taste and versatility in cooking.

white cheddar alternatives infographics

My Final Thoughts On White Cheddar Substitutes

While cheddar is a classic cheese that has a distinct flavor, there are definitely some great substitutes out there that will do the trick in a pinch. Each of the cheeses we’ve listed has its own unique flavor and texture that sets them apart from each other, but they also have a lot of similarities to white cheddar.

So, it really just depends on what you’re looking for in a substitute and what you have on hand. All things considered, any of these five alternatives would make an excellent substitution for white cheddar!

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts