Unbelievable Havarti Cheese Substitutes You Need to Try

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for details.

I’ve always enjoyed the creamy and buttery taste of Havarti cheese, but I know that sometimes it’s not always available at my local grocery store or I might be in the mood for something different.

That’s why I began exploring Havarti cheese substitutes that can still provide a similar taste and texture in my dishes.

In my journey to find awesome replacements, I discovered several options that can work as great as Havarti cheese swaps for various recipes, whether it’s for a cheese platter or a delicious sandwich. Some of these options include Gouda, Monterey Jack, and Colby.

But before we dive in and learn more, let’s learn more about havarti that way we can make the best swap ever!

What Is Havarti Cheese?

As a cheese lover, I geek out by learning where each cheese comes from and how it’s made. Havarti cheese is a Danish cheese that has its origins in Europe.

It was created in the 19th century by Hanne Nielsen, who traveled throughout Europe learning about different cheese-making techniques.

She named her creation, Havarti, after the Danish farm where she lived, called Havarthigaard. This lovely cheese has since become a popular and well-known choice among cheese lovers.

Characteristics of Harvarti

Now that we know the origins of Havarti cheese, let’s dive into some of its characteristic features. Havarti is a semi-soft cheese, which makes it perfect for slicing and melting.

It has a creamy, smooth texture that is absolutely delightful. I also love the flavor of Havarti, as it’s buttery, slightly tangy, and mildly sweet, contributing to its unique and irresistible taste.

To provide a concise look at the characteristics of Havarti cheese, here’s a bullet-point list:

  • Semi-soft cheese
  • Creamy, smooth texture
  • Buttery, slightly tangy, and mildly sweet flavor
  • Perfect for slicing and melting
  • Originated in Denmark (Europe)

The Best Havarti Cheese Substitutes

havarti cheese substitutes

Esrom Cheese

In my experience, Esrom cheese is a great Havarti cheese substitute. Similar to Havarti, it has a semi-soft texture and nutty flavor, making it perfect for sandwiches and other recipes.

Here are some reasons why I like Esrom as a substitute:

  • Semi-soft texture
  • Nutty flavor
  • Works well for sandwiches
  • Can work with a slew of other recipes

Tilsit Cheese

Tilsit Cheese replacing havarti

Tilsit cheese is another good alternative for Havarti cheese. With its creamy texture and tangy, buttery flavor. Some key reasons I choose Tilsit are:

  • Creamy texture
  • Tangy and buttery flavor
  • Melts well
  • Excellent in grilled dishes

Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack cheese is easier to find compared to the other two I have mentioned so far. It has such a wonderful mild flavor and is great for melting.

Its mildness allows it to complement various foods without overpowering other flavors. Here’s why I like Monterey Jack as a sub for Havarti

  • Mild flavor
  • Melts easily
  • Versatile in so many ways
  • Easy to find at supermarkets

Gouda Cheese

Gouda Cheese

I find Gouda cheese to be an excellent Havarti substitute, especially when it comes to texture and flavor. Its smooth, creamy texture and its sweet, nutty taste make it a great choice for dishes.

It does have more flavor than havarti but pairs nicely with many things.

  • Smooth, creamy texture
  • Sweet and nutty flavor
  • Melts well

Edam Cheese

Edam cheese has a similar mild flavor and semi-hard texture that make it a good Havarti substitute.

In my cooking, I’ve found it to work particularly well in recipes that require sliced or grated cheese.

  • Mild flavor
  • Semi-hard texture
  • Easy to slice and grate
  • Good for sandwiches and salads

Fontina Cheese

Lastly, Fontina cheese is another Havarti substitute I consider for its slightly nutty flavor and smooth, creamy texture. Fontina is great in recipes that require melting, and it adds a silky texture and mild flavor to dishes.

  • Slightly nutty flavor
  • Smooth, creamy texture
  • Melts well
  • Ideal for sauces or fondue

The Versatility of Havarti Substitutes

different sliced cheese on brown wooden chopping board

In Sandwiches and Burgers

Havarti cheese is pretty well known for being a great option in sandwiches and burgers.

Gouda, Muenster, Cheddar, and Provolone are my go-to options when I need a Havarti alternative in my sandwiches or burgers.

They each bring their distinct flavor, but also have the right amount of creaminess and melting properties that my grilled cheese or quesadillas crave.

On Cheese Boards

When I’m assembling my cheese board, I like to include a variety of flavors and textures. Havarti is always a popular choice, but I’ve found that Fontina and Gruy√®re also make exceptional additions.

The smooth texture and easy slice-ability of these cheeses ensure they won’t be out of place on any cheese board. Moreover, their unique flavors will definitely please any cheese lover’s palate, just like Havarti would.

In Hot Dishes and Sauces

In hot dishes and sauces, I’ve discovered that the right Havarti substitute can make all the difference. For example, when making a casserole or mac and cheese, I now like to use a mix of Colby Jack and Monterey Jack cheeses.

These two kinds of cheese melt beautifully and bring just the right amount of creaminess to my dishes without overwhelming the other ingredients.

As for fondue, a Havarti replacement I stand by is fontina. It melts smoothly, giving me that perfect ooey-gooey texture.

My Final Thoughts On Substitutes for Havarti

As a home cook, it’s exciting to explore these delicious options when Havarti isn’t available or if I just want to try something new.

With so many flavorful alternatives, I can be confident that my dishes will taste amazing even with a Havarti substitute. So, let’s get creative in the kitchen and have some fun with these cheese options! Happy Cooking!

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts