Turkey Bliss: Best Cheeses For Turkey Sandwiches

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for details.

Who doesn’t love a good turkey sandwich? When it comes to making a delicious turkey sandwich, the type of cheese you use can make all the difference.

So whether you have leftover turkey from Thanksgiving or you picked up some turkey at the deli. Here are some of the best cheese options to make your next sandwich epic!


  • Swiss – Mild, creamy, nutty flavor
  • Sharp Cheddar – Zesty kick complements turkey
  • Havarti – Buttery, creamy taste
  • Pepper Jack – Spicy and melty
  • Smoked Provolone- Rich, flavorful, and melty
Best Cheeses For Turkey Sandwiches

The Best Cheese for Turkey Sandwiches

Mild Cheeses

Mild cheeses are perfect for those who prefer a subtle taste. Here are some mild cheese options that pair well with turkey:

turkey sandwich with provolone
  • Swiss Cheese: With its mild, nutty flavor, Swiss cheese adds a delightful creaminess.
  • Provolone: A semi-hard cheese that is mild and slightly sweet, perfect for a turkey sandwich.
  • Havarti: Known for its buttery taste, Havarti is a creamy cheese that pairs well with turkey.
  • Mozzarella: Its mild taste and smooth texture make mozzarella a versatile choice for turkey sandwiches.
  • Muenster: A mild and slightly tangy cheese that adds a subtle richness to your sandwich.
  • Gouda: With a gentle, sweet flavor, Gouda complements turkey without overwhelming it.
  • Colby Jack: A blend of Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses, offering a mild and creamy combination.
  • Fontina: This semi-soft cheese has a mild, nutty flavor that enhances the turkey experience.
  • Gruyère: While more flavorful, Gruyère’s nutty taste can add a sophisticated touch to your sandwich.
  • White Cheddar: A milder variation of traditional cheddar, white cheddar brings a rich creaminess.

Nutty Cheeses

If you’re looking for a cheese with a nutty flavor, try one of these options:

  • Pecorino Romano: This cheese has a nutty, slightly salty taste, adding delicious flavor to a turkey sandwich. Just make sure to cut this very thin or sprinkle if you have it grated. This would be awesome if you used a panini press and made a hot turkey sandwich.
  • Emmental: Known for its nutty and slightly sweet flavor, Emmental adds a rich and luxurious element to your sandwich.

Tangy Cheeses

Tangy cheeses can add a zing to your turkey sandwich. Here are some tangy cheese options to consider:

  • Blue Cheese: Known for its bold and tangy flavor, it adds a distinctive and robust taste to your turkey sandwich.
  • Feta: With its crumbly texture and tangy taste, feta brings a delightful Mediterranean twist to your turkey creation.
  • Goat Cheese: Creamy and tangy, goat cheese offers a unique and slightly earthy flavor that pairs well with turkey.
  • Sharp Cheddar: While not as tangy as some other options, sharp cheddar provides a zesty kick that can complement the turkey’s mildness.

Spicy Cheeses

If you like your food with a kick, try one of these spicy cheese options:

  • Pepper Jack: This cheese has a spicy kick that pairs well with turkey. It also melts well, making it a great option for a hot turkey sandwich.
  • Chipotle Gouda: Gouda infused with smoky chipotle peppers adds a bold and smoky spiciness that pairs well with the savory taste of turkey.

Recipes for the Best Turkey Sandwiches

turkey sandwich with cheddar
  • Classic Turkey Bliss:
    • Use sourdough bread for a classic base.
    • Layer with mayo or mustard.
    • Add roasted turkey and cheddar or Swiss cheese.
    • Top with arugula or lettuce for crunch.
  • Smoky Delight:
    • Toast two slices of bread for extra flavor.
    • Spread mayo or mustard on each slice.
    • Layer smoked turkey and pepper jack cheese.
    • Enhance with sliced avocado and red onion.
  • Grilled Turkey Elegance:
    • Butter two slices of bread for a golden touch.
    • Utilize leftover turkey with provolone or mozzarella.
    • Grill until the cheese is melted and the bread is golden brown.
  • Light and Fresh Turkey Salad:
    • Chop leftover turkey into mixed greens.
    • Add feta or goat cheese slices or crumbles.
    • Top with sliced almonds or walnuts for crunch.
    • Drizzle with your favorite dressing.

No matter the choice, the right cheese can elevate your turkey sandwich. Explore various combinations for your perfect sandwich experience.

Let’s Wrap Up Finding The Perfect Cheese for Your Turkey Sandwich

Selecting the ideal cheese for your turkey sandwich is made simple with this guide. Explore and have fun…the best cheese for a turkey sandwich is the cheese you enjoy the most!

CheeseFlavor & TextureIdeal Pairings
SwissMild, CreamyIdeal for a subtle taste.
CheddarRobust, Semi-FirmAdds a bold kick to your sandwich.
HavartiCreamy, Slightly SweetPerfect for a milder sweetness.
Blue CheeseStrong, TangyBrings a bold and distinctive flavor.
FetaCrumbly, SaltyOffers a light and tangy touch.

Whether you lean towards mild or robust flavors, there’s a cheese that will elevate your turkey sandwich to perfection. Try out the recommendations and take your sandwich experience to new heights!

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts