The BEST Amaro Nonino Substitutes To Use

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for details.

Amaro Nonino is a versatile Italian liqueur that can be used in cocktails, as an aperitif, or even just sipped on its own. But what do you do when you’re all out and are looking for some Amaro Nonino substitutes? We will go over some of the best alternatives that you can use!  

In the next section though we will go over what Amaro Nonino is and what does it taste like. From understanding those things we can find a good replacement.

Amaro Nonino Substitutes

What Is Amaro Nonino and What Does it Taste Like?

Chances are, you’ve seen a bottle of Amaro Nonino on your favorite restaurant’s backbar or in your local liquor store. But what is this dark, bitter liqueur, and what does it taste like?

Amaro Nonino is a bittersweet liqueur made with a blend of 30 herbs and spices. The exact recipe is a closely guarded family secret, passed down from generation to generation of the Nonino family.

What we do know is that the base spirit is neutral grain alcohol, which is distilled with the herbs and spices. Once the flavor infusion is complete, the mixture is sweetened with sugar and aged in oak barrels for at least 6 months.

This aging process gives Amaro Nonino its signature deep amber color and complex flavor profile. On the nose, you’ll pick up hints of orange peel, clove, and cinnamon. The taste is bittersweet, with more citrus notes up front followed by a long herbal finish.

Amaro Nonino is a versatile ingredient that can be used in all sorts of cocktails. It’s equally delicious on its own, served neat or over ice. If you’re looking for something a little lighter, try it in a spritz with equal parts Amaro Nonino and sparkling water.

Substitutes for Amaro Nonino

Amaro Nonino cocktail alternative

Amaro Averna

Amaro Averna is a bitter Italian liqueur that has been produced in Caltanissetta, Sicily since 1868 by Salvatore Averna. If you’re out of Amaro Nonino, Amaro Averna is a good substitution. Amaro Averna is made with herbs, roots, and citrus peel, and has a spicy yet herbal flavor. It has notes of caramel, anise, citrus, and honey. It’s also a bit sweeter than Amaro Nonino and is considered quite rich.

This liqueur is dark brown in color and has a complex flavor that is both sweet and bitter. It is an essential ingredient in the Amaro Negroni cocktails, and it can also be used to add depth and richness to other drinks. Whether you are enjoying it on its own or using it as a mixology tool, Amaro Averna is a versatile liqueur that is sure to add interest to your next drink.

Amaro Tosolini 

Amaro Tosolini is another good substitute for Amaro Nonino. It’s made with herbs, roots, and fruits, and has notes of cinnamon and clove. Amaro Tosolini is less sweet than Amaro Averna but more sweet than Amaro Nonino. 

Amaro Tosolini has a deep amber color and a complex flavor profile. A beautiful mix of citrus, stewed fruits, and bitters that compliment this amaro so well. It is often served neat or on the rocks, but it can also be used in cocktails. When used in cocktails, Amaro Tosolini adds a warm, herbal flavor that pairs well with spirits such as whiskey and rum.

Amaro Montenegro 

Amaro Montenegro is a good option for Amaro Nonino substitute but it is more on the sweeter side. It’s made with citrus peel, nutmeg, and liquorice, and has hints of cola, vanilla and orange blossom. 

It is an herbal liqueur that has been produced in Italy since 1885. The recipe for the liqueur is known to contain over 40 different herbs and spices.

Amaro Montenegro is typically served as an after-dinner digestif, and it is often used as a base for cocktails. The liqueur has a bittersweet flavor, but it tends to be more on the sweet side compared to other amaros. Because of it’s orange background it pairs well with cocktail that use orange juice.

Amaro Montenegro is produced by macerating herbs and spices in alcohol, which is then diluted with water and sweetened with sugar. The mixture is then left to mature in oak barrels for at least a year.

After maturing, the liqueur is bottled and distributed worldwide. Amaro Montenegro has won numerous awards and accolades over the years, and it remains one of the most popular herbal liqueurs on the market today.


Ramazzotti is another option that’s not too sweet and not too bitter. It is an Italian herbal liqueur that has been produced since 1815 by herbalist, Ausano Ramazzotti. It is made with a blend of 33 different herbs and spices, including cardamom, Cinnamon, Juniper berries, citrus peel, and star anise.

Ramazzotti is typically served as an after-dinner digestif, but it can also be used in a variety of cocktails. The most popular way to enjoy Ramazzotti is to mix it with ginger ale or cola. One refreshing version is is often referred to as a Rama Summer Cup.

While it is not as well-known as some other Italian liqueurs, such as Amaretto or Limoncello, Ramazzotti is beloved by many for its unique flavor profile and versatility. Whether you enjoy it on its own or in a mixed drink, Ramazzotti is a great substitute for Amaro Nonino.


Jägermeister is actually a German liqueur, but it can work as a substitute for Amaro Nonino in a pinch. It’s made with 56 different herbs, fruits, roots, and spices (the exact recipe is a closely guarded secret), and has hints of licorice, anise, prune, damsons, cola, and dark chocolate. Jägermeister is sweeter than all of the other amaros on this list. 

Jägermeisteris typically served cold, and it is often used as a shot or in cocktails. The drink gets its name from the German word for “master of the hunt” and it has long been associated with hunting culture.


Cynar is an artichoke-based liqueur that originated in Italy, And it makes a good substitution for Amaro Nonino. The drink gets its name from the Cynara cardunculus, the scientific name for the artichoke plant, but it also includes 12 more botanicals. Cynar is known for its distinctive bottle, which features a cartoon like artichoke as its logo.

The liqueur is also recognizable for its bittersweet taste, which is often used to balance out sweet cocktails. While Cynar can be enjoyed chilled on it’s own, it is most commonly used mixed in cocktails.

In recent years, Cynar has also become popular as an ingredient in craft cocktails. bartenders appreciate its unique flavor and its ability to add depth to a drink. It’s slightly bitter with hints of quinine bitterness and toffee.

Gammel Dansk

Gammel Dansk has its roots in Norway and Denmark. And it can make for good substitute for Amaro Nonino. It’s made with 29 different herbs, berries, and aromatic oils. As for flavor it leads with bitterness with hints of juniper pine, liquorice, and berries. Gammel Dansk tends me be more bitter than all of the other amaros on this list except. 

Because Gammel Dansk has a strong, somewhat bitter flavor that many people find to be pleasantly refreshing. It is also said to have medicinal properties and to be effective in calming the stomach like other amaros. If you are looking for a unique substitute for Amaro Nonino this one fits the bill.

Amaro Nonino replacement infographic

My Final Thoughts on Amaro Nonino Substitutes

There are many different liqueurs that can be used as substitutes for Amaro Nonino. When choosing a substitute, it’s important to consider the sweetness level as well as the flavor profile. Some of the best substitutes for Amaro Nonino include Amaro Averna, Amaro Tosolini, Ramazzotti, Cynar, and Gammel Dansk.

The BEST Amaro Nonino Substitutes To Use

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts