The Best Shutter Colors for a Red Brick House

There’s something timeless about a red brick home. It’s warm, classic, and full of character. But here’s the thing about brick: it’s a big, bold feature that never goes away, so whatever color you pair with it really matters. And few choices make more of a difference than your shutters.

Shutters frame your windows, add depth, and give your whole exterior a finished, thoughtful look. The right color can make your brick feel richer, more elegant, or wonderfully fresh.

The wrong one? It can fight with those red undertones and leave everything feeling a little “off.”

Before we jump in, one quick tip that’ll guide every choice below: take a close look at your brick. Red brick isn’t just one color. Some leans orange and warm, some pulls toward pink or rose, and some has cool, brownish-gray flecks running through it.

>> 12 Great Red Brick House Exterior Color Schemes

Knowing your brick’s undertone is the secret to picking shutters that truly belong.

Let’s walk through seven shutter colors that pair beautifully with red brick, so you can find the one that feels like you.

White

White shutters are the crisp, cheerful classic that almost never lets you down. Against red brick, white creates bright, high contrast that makes your windows pop and gives the whole facade a clean, welcoming feel. It’s the kind of look that reads “charming cottage” or “polished colonial” depending on your home’s shape.

One thing worth knowing: not all whites are created equal. Pure, stark white can look a little harsh next to warm brick, so a soft white with a slight creamy or gray undertone usually feels more natural.

To keep everything cohesive, echo the white on your trim and consider a bold front door in navy, black, or even a punchy red to add personality.

This is a wonderful choice if you want your home to feel light, timeless, and easy on the eyes.

Black

If you love a look that feels modern and a little dramatic, black shutters are hard to beat. Black grounds all that warmth in the brick and adds instant sophistication. It’s sharp, confident, and pairs especially well with brick that has cooler, darker undertones.

Black plays nicely with almost any trim, but white trim is the classic partner here, giving you that clean black-and-white contrast against the red. For the front door, you can either match the black for a sleek, cohesive feel or go with a rich wood tone to warm things up.

The beauty of black is its versatility. Traditional home? It looks stately. More contemporary? It looks intentional and current. Either way, it’s a safe bet that always looks pulled together.

Navy Blue

Navy is one of those colors that feels both classic and unexpected, and it’s genuinely stunning against red brick. The deep blue offers enough contrast to stand out, but it’s softer and more inviting than black. Think coastal charm meets timeless elegance.

Navy really shines with brick that has warmer, orange-red undertones, since the cool blue creates a balanced, harmonious contrast. Pair it with crisp white trim to keep things fresh, and think about a front door in a matching navy, a warm natural wood, or even a cheerful yellow if you’re feeling playful.

Choose navy when you want something a touch more interesting than black but just as dependable.

>> 20 Painted Brick House Exterior Color Ideas for a Fresh New Look

Sage Green

Sage green is the quiet favorite that keeps winning people over. This soft, muted green feels earthy and calm, and it complements red brick in a way that feels almost effortless. Since green and red sit opposite each other on the color wheel, they naturally balance one another, giving your home a settled, harmonious look.

Sage works especially well with brick that has warm, reddish-orange tones. It leans into that garden-inspired, lived-in charm that suits farmhouses, cottages, and craftsman-style homes beautifully. Keep your trim in a soft white or cream to let the green breathe, and a warm wood or deep green door will tie it all together.

Pick sage if you want your home to feel welcoming, grounded, and a little bit unexpected.

Charcoal Gray

Charcoal is black’s softer, more subtle cousin, and it’s a fantastic middle-ground option. You get that same grounding, sophisticated effect, but with a gentler feel that doesn’t demand quite as much attention. Against red brick, charcoal adds depth and a modern edge without going fully dark.

This color is a great match for brick with cooler, grayish undertones, since the gray tones speak the same language. Charcoal pairs handsomely with white or light gray trim, and it opens the door to some really nice front door options: think a rich navy, a bold red, or a warm wood stain.

Reach for charcoal when you want the elegance of black with a touch more warmth and flexibility.

Cream

If white feels a bit too crisp for your taste, cream is the softer, cozier alternative. This warm, buttery neutral blends beautifully with red brick, especially brick that leans warm and orange. Instead of sharp contrast, cream creates a gentle, harmonious look that feels traditional and inviting.

Because cream carries warmth, it tends to flatter the reddish tones in brick rather than compete with them. Keep your trim in a coordinating cream or soft white so everything feels seamless, and add a pop of personality with a front door in deep green, warm brown, or classic black.

Cream is the way to go if you love a subtle, timeless, and comfortable feel over bold contrast.

Deep Brown

For a look that’s rich, natural, and full of warmth, deep brown shutters are a beautiful choice. Brown leans into the earthy side of red brick and creates a cohesive, organic feel, almost like your home grew right out of the landscape. It’s especially lovely on craftsman, rustic, and traditional homes.

Deep brown works wonderfully with warm-toned brick, and you can lean into that wood-inspired look with stained or faux-wood shutters for extra texture. Pair them with cream or tan trim to keep things soft, and a front door in a matching wood tone or deep green will complete that cozy, natural palette.

Choose deep brown when you want your home to feel warm, welcoming, and connected to nature.

Choosing the Right Shutter Color for Your Home

So how do you land on the one? It really comes down to three things.

First, think about contrast. Want your windows to pop with a bold, striking look? Go with black, navy, or charcoal. Prefer something softer and more blended? Cream, sage, and deep brown will feel gentle and cohesive.

Next, pay attention to your undertones. Warm, orange-red brick loves warm partners like cream, sage, deep brown, and navy. Cooler, grayer brick tends to shine alongside charcoal and black.

Finally, consider your home’s style. A colonial or cottage sings with white, while a modern facade loves black or charcoal. Craftsman and farmhouse homes feel right at home with sage or brown.

There’s no single “correct” answer here, only the shade that makes your brick, and your style, feel like the best version of itself. Trust your eye, look at samples in natural light, and go with the color that makes you smile every time you pull into the driveway.

Sharing is caring!